If you missed part one: I ordered a GoPro from Amazon, received a bottle of baby oil, returned it, got a refund, and then Amazon charged me £289.26 for not returning the GoPro I never had. Five contacts and three months later, I’d collected three promises that I wouldn’t be charged, one charge, and no resolution. The post ended by wondering which mechanism had turned Customer Obsession into Customer Patience.
Turns out the mechanism was a form and one person who actually read the notes.
Contact six: 17 November#
After contact five I’d been told the refund required an Incident Report form. The form arrived, I filled it in, and emailed it back. That was the easy part. The hard part, as usual, was getting back in the chat to confirm someone had received it.
I opened with a summary for the chatbot: sixth contact, previously told the charge wouldn’t happen, then told to let it happen and I’d be refunded, which didn’t happen either, and I’d now submitted the incident report as instructed. The chatbot acknowledged I’d been “dealing with this issue multiple times”, which felt like the understatement of the quarter, and put me through to an associate.
I asked them to read the full order history and escalate if they couldn’t fix it — “and honestly we’ve both got better things to do with our lives.” The associate replied with the familiar “nothing to worry, I’ll be more than happy to look into this for you,” and I told them they’d all said that so far, following the script, and yet here we were.
A long pause. A “still on it.” Me asking if they were still there. I told them that Amazon owed me £289.26, so I was vested in getting this resolved. They transferred me to a specialist.
The specialist asked what had happened. I explained, one more time, that someone between the fulfilment centre and the driver had swapped a GoPro for a bottle of baby oil, so I couldn’t return a camera I’d never received. I asked straight out whether she could resolve this or whether we were going to chat for a bit following the script and giving me false hope.
She said she could see the previous notes and the submitted incident report, and that she could request the refund.
That was it. A few minutes, one person with the authority and tools to act, and it was done. £289.26 refunded to the original payment method, expected within seven business days.
I signed off: “You’re the best — thanks for sorting — hopefully I won’t have to be in touch again on this.” A brief, grudging Day 1 moment. An adult in the room, at last.
The updated tally#
- 6 contacts, roughly 11 humans (associates, supervisors and a specialist), plus a lot of chatbot
- 3 explicit promises that I would not be charged
- 1 charge taken: £289.26
- 1 form that unlocked everything, first mentioned on contact five, after the charge
- Time the specialist took once she’d read the notes: a few minutes
- Refund: pending (up to 7 business days)
- GoPros received at any point in this process: still 0
What actually worked#
Having the incident report already on file. Asking straight out whether the person could resolve it. Getting passed to someone with the authority to act. That was always enough — it just took six contacts, a form nobody mentioned for three months, and £289.26 leaving my account before the process surfaced it.
The people were fine. Every associate I spoke to agreed it was wrong. The specialist fixed it in minutes. The lesson for Amazon isn’t about its people — it’s that the fix existed all along, and the mechanism kept it behind a gate that only opened after the customer had been charged. If you’re reading this mid-saga with a wrong-item return: ask early whether there’s an incident report or form, and save every chat.
I’ll believe it’s over when the money lands.
Update: Awaiting refund. I’ll update this post when it arrives.